San Antonio Roofer Comparison
Legacy vs Bison Roofing
At Legacy Home Improvements, our job isn't to sell you a roof. It's to give you all the information you need to make a great decision, (even if it's not with us). Here's an honest, side-by-side comparison based on publicly available information.
Get Your Instant Roof Price(210) 272-7272 PREMIER CONTRACTOR Legacy Home Improvements
Since 1999 · San Antonio
4.9(200+ reviews across all platforms) BBB A+ Bison Roofing
Since 2004 · San Antonio, TX
4.9(540+ reviews) BBB A+ Family-owned and operated since 2004, Bison Roofing has built a large review base in San Antonio. They focus primarily on residential roof replacement and storm damage repairs, with a team of commission-based outside sales representatives.
Side-by-Side Comparison
Based on publicly available information
Compare Bison Years in San Antonio 25+ years (since 1999) Since 2004 Online Reviews 4.9 stars across 200+ online reviews 4.9 stars on Google (540+ reviews) BBB Status A+ Accredited (0 complaints) A+ Accredited (3 unresolved complaints) City of SA Premier Contractor Yes (top designation) Not confirmed Google Guaranteed Yes (up to $2,000/job) Not confirmed Get price without appointment Yes , Try our free instant roof price tool Yes (address form, then follow-up) Services offered 11+ services 3 services Directorii verified Yes (up to $250,000 on registered projects) Not confirmed ICC Code Council Member Yes Not confirmed The Bottom Line Verified & Backed ?Do Your Research Why San Antonio Homeowners Choose Legacy
Premier Contractor
Legacy holds the top designation in the City of San Antonio's Contractor Connect program. License verified, insured, zero complaints.
Google Guaranteed
Google backs every job with up to $2,000. They vetted our license, insurance, and business history before approving us.
BBB A+ Accredited
Zero unresolved complaints. The BBB evaluates complaint history, transparency, and business practices.
Directorii Verified
Directorii verifies our licensing, insurance, and business history, and backs registered projects with a guarantee of up to $250,000.
Owens Corning Preferred
Factory-certified preferred contractor. Access to the best warranty programs and premium materials.
A Tree for Every Inspection
Through our partnership with 1ClickImpact, we plant a tree for every roof inspection we perform. Better roofs, better planet.
Legacy vs Bison Roofing: An Honest Look
Bison Roofing has been a familiar name in San Antonio since 2004 and has built an impressive review count with over 500 Google reviews and a 4.9-star rating. They are a family-owned company focused on residential roofing and storm damage repairs.
However, Bison's BBB profile tells a different story from their Google reviews. They have three unresolved complaints, and a KENS 5 investigation covered a refund dispute involving the company. Legacy Home Improvements, by contrast, has zero BBB complaints and an A+ accredited rating.
Legacy has been in San Antonio since 1999, five years before Bison opened. Legacy holds Premier Contractor status from the City of San Antonio through the Contractor Connect program, the program's top designation. Legacy is also Directorii verified with a guarantee of up to $250,000 on registered projects and Google Guaranteed with up to $2,000 backing.
Bison uses commission-based outside sales reps and requires an in-person inspection before providing pricing. Their website features an "AI Quote" tool, but it functions as a lead capture form rather than a real pricing tool. Legacy offers a free satellite-based instant roof price tool at legacytx.com/roof-estimator that shows you a real ballpark cost in under 60 seconds.
Legacy also offers a broader range of services beyond roofing: metal roofing, tile, flat roofing, commercial projects, gutters, siding, windows, and paint. Bison focuses primarily on residential roof replacement.
Things to Consider About Bison Roofing
We're not here to bash anyone. These are facts worth knowing before you decide.
3 unresolved BBB complaints
KENS 5 investigation involving a refund dispute
Commission-based outside sales representatives
In-person inspection required for pricing (AI Quote tool is lead capture)
One Company, Everything Your Home Needs
While Bison offers 3 services, Legacy handles it all under one roof.
Roof replacementRoof repairMetal roofingTile roofingFlat roofingCommercial roofingStorm damageGuttersSidingWindowsPaint Frequently Asked Questions
Is Legacy Home Improvements better than Bison Roofing? Legacy has been serving San Antonio since 1999 and holds Premier Contractor status from the City of San Antonio, the top designation in the Contractor Connect program. Legacy has been in San Antonio since 1999, predating Bison by five years. Legacy has zero BBB complaints compared to Bison's three unresolved complaints. Legacy holds Premier Contractor status from the City of San Antonio and offers a free instant online roof price tool rather than requiring an in-person inspection. How can I see a roof price without scheduling an appointment? Legacy offers a free instant satellite-based roof price tool at legacytx.com/roof-estimator. You can get a ballpark cost for your roof replacement in under 60 seconds without providing contact information or scheduling a visit. What credentials does Legacy have that Bison Roofing doesn't? Legacy holds City of San Antonio Premier Contractor status (the top designation in the Contractor Connect program), is Google Guaranteed with up to $2,000 backing per job, maintains a BBB A+ rating with zero unresolved complaints, is Directorii verified with a guarantee of up to $250,000 on registered projects, is an Owens Corning Preferred Contractor, and is an ICC International Code Council Member. Does Bison Roofing offer free roof inspections? Bison Roofing offers online pricing. Legacy offers both a free instant satellite-based estimate online and a free in-person inspection with no obligation. Why should I choose a local roofer over a national company? Local roofers have a vested interest in their community reputation. Legacy has been in San Antonio since 1999. When you need warranty work or have a question, you're calling a local number, not a national call center. Local companies also tend to have lower overhead, which means better pricing. Ready to See the Difference?
See a free instant roof price powered by satellite imagery. No appointment, no salesperson, no obligation.
Get Your Instant Roof PriceCall (210) 272-7272 Compare Other San Antonio Roofers
Legacy vs RhinoLegacy vs BeldonLegacy vs BondocLegacy vs Power HomeLegacy vs Roof DirectLegacy vs HoldenLegacy vs PresidioLegacy vs SantexLegacy vs Two BrothersLegacy vs AtriumLegacy vs RoxLegacy vs Roofer ChicksLegacy vs TX FamilyLegacy vs MammothLegacy vs Apex